top of page

How the wind energy rush is tearing up the Amazon

Updated: Nov 9


Although the wind turbine industry fiercely drives the wheel of the global green transition, its underlying supply chain is highly destructive.


Jerry Oldenettel / Flickr / CC BY-NC-SA 2.0
Jerry Oldenettel / Flickr / CC BY-NC-SA 2.0

Although the wind turbine industry fiercely drives the wheel of the global green transition, its underlying supply chain is highly destructive. Modern wind turbines are incredibly complex machineries, requiring an internal core that is lightweight yet highly resistant to compression. Balsa wood is uniquely suited for this due to its unmatched stiffness-to-density ratio. When balsa is kiln-dried, it sheds its moisture and leaves behind a honey-comb like framework that provides turbine blades with sheer resistance and compression strength to withstand severe wind pressure. Although many efforts have been made to replace balsa, all synthetic materials and plastic foams like polyethylene terephthalate (PET) have failed to provide the structural rigidity needed to endure extreme weather.


These unique properties of balsa establish it as an irreplaceable industrial necessity. Turbine blades routinely exceed 100 meters in length, and a single mega-offshore wind turbine can consume up to 450 cubic metres of balsa across its three blades. Since manufacturers failed to replace Balsa completely and due to balsa’s high demand, manufacturers adapted to hybrid core, which utilizes plastic forms at low stress sections while reserving balsa for high dynamic and high-stress load points.

A global rush

Between 2019 and 2020, a global rush for wind turbine installation occurred, primarily driven by two major global subsidies: US Production Tax Credit (PTC) and China ‘s feed-in tariffs. Due to their strict deadlines, global manufacturers frantically accelerated their manufacturing quotas to secure tax credits and government payout. Ecuador, which accounts for roughly 90% of global balsa, saw its balsa export valued at $127 million dollars in 2019, which further skyrocketed to $400 million dollars in 2020. Although balsa is a fast-growing species that rapidly colonizes riverbanks and small islands, it still requires 3 to 5 years to reach commercial maturity. This biological bottleneck and the surging manufacturing pace squeezed the legitimate supply chain. All legal plantations—small patches of balsa specifically grown for extraction and exportation—were exhausted of mature balsa, which drove the price of a single standing balsa from $5 to as high as $45 dollars. Since legal plantation wood vanished and financial incentives were high, timber mafias (locally known as “Balseros”) logged deep into the Amazon rainforest. They began harvesting wild balsa—which constitutes unregulated and illegal timber extracted from indigenous lands—and funneling it into a global clean market.


To obtain wild, illegal balsa, timber mafias organize from the coast and travel across the Andean mountain range. The road infrastructure abruptly ends in frontier towns like Puyo and shell, situated in the upper basin at the foothill of the Andes, which forces them to to load their chainsaws and supplies into canoes. Then, they navigate downstream cutting directly through the constitutionally recognized and ancestral territories of indigenous communities such as Waorani, Achuar, Shuar, Khichwa and Sapara people. Since the Amazonian interior lacked paved roads, the river systems became the highway for illicit trade. Timber mafias choked these vital river systems such as copataza, conambo and bobonaza with fleets of diesel-chugging canoes to locate and transport specific patches of balsa.


These ancestral territories are collectively governed by elected federations. However, instead of asking for permission, timber mafias, locally known as balseros, deliberately bypassed regional governance and directly approached isolated, impoverished communities. 

Community impact

 “Given that the Ecuadorian government didn’t have a very effective and efficient wild balsa management and monitoring system there were barely any barriers for illegal loggers to make a deal with the local community.” Haibing Ma, the EIA’s Asia policy specialist and lead author of the ILL WIND report, said. 


Balseros are subsidized by middlemen called acopiadores, meaning the entire operation—including chainsaws, canoes, and fuel—is backed by them. Their arrival has brought severe sociological hazards to the indigenous area. In exchange for timber on communal land, they offered chainsaws, cheap smartphones, sugarcane liquor like Aguardiente and a negligible amount of hard cash that is a small fraction of the actual industrial price.


“The profit from balsa wood does not stay in the communities,” Acción Ecológica‘s 2021 balsa trade report states. “The price paid per standing cubic foot inside the forest is negligible compared to the exported processed value, leaving precarious daily wages, labor exploitation, and depleted resources.” 


While a substantial amount of money does not return to the local, the sudden influx of capital and alcohol can lead to severe alcohol dependency, domestic violence, internal division, and a breakdown of traditional cultural values. 


The hunger for securing tax credits and subsidies enlarged the wind industry’s appetite enough to trigger a massive cross-border crisis. By late 2020, the Ecuadorian Amazon was so thoroughly depleted of mature balsa that balseros had to look elsewhere. They moved South, crossed the international border, and entered into the Peruvian Amazon. Balseros invaded the ancestral territories of Peruvian indigenous communities such as the Wampis and Awajún, sparking intense conflict. In one dramatic instance, the Wampis government fiercely resisted timber theft by setting up physical blockades and confiscating the timber. In return, the Ecuadorian loggers kidnapped a Wampis child and held her hostage as a leverage to demand the release of confiscated timber.


Chopping down balsa directly undermines the long-term survival capabilities of the indigenous communities. When balseros indiscriminately clear-cut balsa, the soil loses its structural anchor; resulting soil erosion is catastrophic and hazardous. Soil floods into the water and pollutes the benthic spawning beds of native fish, which constitute up to 70% of indigenous communities’ animal protein. This ecological degradation also threatens wildlife. Removing balsa starves over 22 species of canopy-dwelling mammals and birds, including kinkajous, capuchins, and nectar-feeding bats that depend on the trees for crucial dry-season sustenance.

No more parrots

“To the islands that form in the Villano River, where there are many balsa trees, many animals arrive attracted by the flowers, such as the paca, the agouti and the armadillos,” Acción Ecológica’s 2021 balsa trade report notes. “Where there is no longer balsa, they have gone, they have migrated; you no longer hear the parrots in these parts of the islands.”


While the ecosystem suffocates and wildlife starves, the wild harvested timber is brought to coastal mills like those in Guayaquil. The Guia de movilizacion is a transit permit that proves the wood originates from a legal plantation. Here’s how the middlemen exploit a major loophole to bypass highway enforcements: They purchase a small legal plantation patch, obtain the transit permit, and then repeatedly reuse or photocopy the exact permit to transport massive volumes of balsa. When the trucks reach the exporting hubs such as Guayaquil, the illegally harvested timber and legal plantation timber look identical because the middlemen saw them into blocks, making them look exactly the same.


“The key is the mixing mechanism,” Haibing Ma explains. “Balsa exporters usually mix wild harvested balsa into legal plantation grown to achieve the optimal density.”  He notes that while legal plantation trees require about five years to reach optimal density, the 2019–2020 global rush completely exhausted the legitimate legal supply chain. To feed the frantic manufacturing pace, exporters turned to a quick, illicit alternative: mixing low-density harvest from young plantation trees with high-density, mature wild timber.


To import this illicit supply, global manufacturers rely on Forest Stewardship Certification (FSC). They frequently hide behind the “FSC mix” category, which is a loophole that legally permits the exporters to merge plantation grown balsa with illegally harvested wild balsa.


“Certification can seem like a quick fix… but is in fact a false solution that allows timber and other products linked to illegalities to flood the international market carrying a green label,” Laura Shirra White, a researcher at Earthsight, warns.

This multi-tiered approach also exposes a mathematical impossibility. Ecuadorian legal plantation supply chain is mathematically incapable of satisfying the global production quota alone, which uncovers how exporters use FSC rubber-stamp to supply wild harvested balsa.


However, supply chain accountability may finally be tightened. Chris Moye of the Environmental Investigation Agency notes that while previous laws have struggled, “the much stronger European Union Deforestation Regulation (EUDR)… should raise the due-diligence bar for checking on the imports of high-risk Amazon timber in general.”



How the Wind Energy Rush is Tearing up the Amazon was first published by the Youth Environmental Press Team under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.  

Comments


By revealing the power of nature and human agency, our storytelling instills a sense of awe that inspires stewardship and innovation toward the landscapes that shape us. 

Join Our Mailing List

  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • Whatsapp
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page