top of page

The toxic cost of clean energy: how South Asia’s youth pay for the global green transition

Updated: Nov 9


For a few cents’ worth of copper wire pulled from decommissioned Western solar panels, they inhale a toxic dust of lead and cadmium that damages their DNA and stunts neurodevelopment, all while chemical leaching quietly poisons the surrounding farmland.


UNESCO-UNEVOC / Flickr / CC BY-NC-SA 2.0
UNESCO-UNEVOC / Flickr / CC BY-NC-SA 2.0

In the narrow alleys of the scrap market, the constant strike of hammers against metal sets a relentless rhythm. Sitting barefoot in soil dark with chemical runoff, young women and children smash apart discarded electronics with their bare hands, breathing in the acrid black smoke that hangs perpetually over the yard. For a few cents’ worth of copper wire pulled from decommissioned Western solar panels, they inhale a toxic dust of lead and cadmium that damages their DNA and stunts neurodevelopment, all while chemical leaching quietly poisons the surrounding farmland. This is South Asia today: the hidden, toxic shadow of the global clean energy transition.


This humanitarian and ecological crisis is the ground-level price of the global clean energy transition: technologies built to save the climate ending up in toxic piles across the Global South. The Basel Convention, designed to track the transboundary movement of all electronic waste, is actively being exploited. Global brokers manipulate Paragraph 31(b), the “repairables loophole,” which creates an ambiguous legal distinction between waste and usable goods, falsely labeling their shipments as charity donations or usable electronics destined for refurbishment to legally bypass strict global mandates, specifically the requirement for Prior Informed Consent (PIC).


“The global waste trade relies on a critical blind spot at transshipment hubs: the switched bill of lading,” Senior Advisor of Nexus3 Foundation, Yuyun Ismawati Drwiega said. “By doctoring these transit documents, brokers effectively erase the original exporter’s paper trail. Armed with this fraudulent paperwork and manipulated Harmonized System (HS) codes, they blindside customs inspectors, bypass red-channel scrutiny and reroute hazardous waste directly into unregulated scrapyards.”


This legal evasion is not theoretical. It is proven by physical forensic tracking. 


Global brokers break the paper trail into two legs,” Hayley Palmer of the Basel Action Network (BAN) said. 


The tactic relies on landing the material at a proxy point with a working resale market and weak oversight. From there, a local broker handles the second, harder-to-trace journey into South Asia, effectively snapping the original chain of custody.The Basel team tracked this exact pattern using GPS devices hidden inside discarded electronics. In one instance, a printer originating from a US recycler in Texas was shipped to a broker in Hong Kong, who then re-exported the unit to Karachi and onward to Lahore. Similarly, a tracked UK device bypassed direct routes, passing through multiple intermediaries before arriving at an informal repair shop in Rawalpindi.


Physically, they hide the hazardous waste deep inside the container by packing the front doors with working tech. Once cleared, the shipments are handed over to short-lived front companies registered under proxy names or fake National Tax Numbers (NTNs). These containers bypass commercial warehouses and drive directly to informal recycling hubs. By the time environmental regulators realize illegal e-waste has entered the country, the importing company no longer exists, and the physical waste has already been dismantled by hand.


“Under the guise of ‘second-hand goods,’ foreign exporters systematically bypass Basel restrictions, and the vast majority of these containers entering South Asian ports carry products that are completely non-functional. It is dead technology dumped onto developing nations under the cover of trade,” Priti Mahesh, former Chief Program Coordinator said. “When regulatory bodies attempt to track these importing entities, they frequently disappear behind proxy names and fake tax registration numbers that no longer exist.”


The geography of global e-waste dumping has shifted dramatically. Until 2018, China was the world’s largest recycling hub and absorbed roughly 70% of global e-waste. However, after China enacted its Operation National Sword policy to ban most foreign scrap imports, global brokers desperately rerouted their shipments to Southeast Asia. While the region absorbed the initial blow, massive public outcry triggered fierce port crackdowns, with Malaysian authorities successfully identifying and blocking over 120 shipments of illegal e-waste. These restrictions forced brokers to redirect their cargo toward the path of least resistance: South Asian ports like Karachi, Pakistan and Chittagong, Bangladesh. Despite maintaining strict hazardous waste laws, Bangladesh illegally imported nearly 15,000 tons of e-waste over the last three years, transforming local scrapyards into international hazard zones. 


The clean energy industry frequently argues that solar panels and Electric Vehicle (EV) batteries are completely safe while intact. However, the informal dismantling and smashing of these technologies in South Asian scrapyards triggers a massive public health crisis. 


While the exterior of solar panels is covered with glass and aluminium, the deep-seated toxic metals lead and cadmium pose massive health hazards. When unprotected workers smash the tempered glass to extract valuable copper wire and silver, they aerosolize these toxic metals into a fine dust. Inhaling lead dust directly damages the central nervous system and stunts neurodevelopment in youth, while chronic cadmium exposure severely damages the kidneys and leads to bone demineralization. Furthermore, when workers burn the polymer bindings to break down the cells, the panels’ protective encapsulations are destroyed, which allows worthless remnants of lead and cadmium to react instantly with rainwater and leach directly into the soil and groundwater, poisoning the local agricultural supply.


EV batteries pose an even more volatile threat. Lithium-ion batteries are highly complex chemical engines, and their cathodes are built from nickel, manganese and cobalt, all suspended in highly reactive liquid electrolytes. To extract the valuable metals like cobalt and nickel, informal workers utilize crude acid baths using aqua regia, a highly corrosive mixture of nitric and hydrochloric acid. This process dissolves the metals and degrades the battery’s electrolyte, typically lithium hexafluorophosphate, into lethal hydrofluoric acid gas. When inhaled without industrial respirators, Hydrogen fluoride (HF) gas causes immediate pulmonary edema, destroys deep tissue, and decalcifies human bone. This unregulated extraction also exposes workers to toxic cobalt dust, leading to severe respiratory distress, asthma and cardiovascular failure. Finally, the open-pit burning of battery casings releases persistent organic pollutants, such as polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs). These toxins accumulate in the bloodstreams of residents living miles downwind, causing permanent endocrine disruption and immune system failure.


In Karachi’s Shershah Market, environmental researchers found soil lead levels 300 times higher than the World Health Organization’s safety standards. A landmark study by Aga Khan University revealed that 92% of informal recyclers in the area exhibited blood lead levels eight times higher than the threshold at which the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends immediate medical intervention, with 76% suffering from Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD).


In India, research by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) revealed copper contamination in soil exceeding U.S. Environmental Protection Agency standards, along with a staggering soil lead concentration of 2,645 mg/kg across Mandoli and Seelampur in Delhi.


Likewise, a case study in Bangladesh found that 100% of tested children near informal recycling sites had elevated blood lead levels, some reaching 48 µg/dL, a toxic concentration requiring emergency medical intervention for potential kidney and brain damage. Nationwide, roughly 60% of all Bangladeshi children exhibit blood lead levels high enough to cause severe neurodevelopmental harm.


Across Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh, hundreds of thousands of underage workers are sacrificing their neurological futures just to extract a few cents’ worth of copper and silver from discarded clean-tech e-waste.


Sonia Buftheim, former Co-Chair for the International Pollutants Elimination Network (IPEN) Youth Caucus, warned:

“Young workers are particularly vulnerable because their bodies are still developing and are generally more sensitive to toxic exposures. Repeated exposure may also contribute to longer-term neurological, developmental, or reproductive effects,” she said. “Toxic dust and contaminants released during informal recycling can spread into nearby homes, schools, farmland and water sources.”


Priti Mahesh, former Chief Program Coordinator at Toxics Link, confirmed this tragic reality, and stated, “Women in informal recycling hubs, whether dismantling tech themselves or living nearby, face immense reproductive health issues, including high rates of early pregnancy loss and children born with physical deformities and developmental deficiencies. Their bodies are absorbing toxic heavy metals every single day.”


The legal architecture of global dumping is finally cracking. The newly enacted January 2025 Basel Convention amendments, specifically the Y49 waste classification, have legally closed the Paragraph 31(b) loophole. By mandating Prior Informed Consent (PIC) for all electronic waste, this regulatory shift officially restricts the global brokers who previously bypassed international trade mandates by falsely labeling their toxic shipments as “repairable goods.”


“To effectively intercept illegal e-waste, recipient governments must maintain strict enforcement directly at customs,” Professor David Hunter of American University said. “Ports must remain the primary interdiction point. Authorities must mandate that any potential waste entering the country is already destined for a pre-identified, verified recycling system, while tracking all materials as they leave the exporting country, enter the port, and arrive at the final disposal site.”


However, border policies alone cannot fix a fundamentally-flawed economic model. To truly solve this crisis, global climate finance must mandate a bonded disposal fund for every new clean energy project. Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) must be baked into the very foundation of green investments. 


To combat this, Hayley Palmer argues these EPR programs must “set recycler pay through a fair, multi-stakeholder process,” preventing illicit cash markets from undercutting compliant facilities. This ensures that the Global North’s clean energy generation is not subsidized by the health and neurological safety of vulnerable communities in the Global South.


A truly just transition demands accountability at the end of the supply chain. The technologies built to save the global climate cannot continue to leave a toxic legacy for the people forced to dismantle them.



The Toxic Cost of Clean Energy: How South Asia’s Youth Pay for the Global Green Transition was first published by the Youth Environmental Press Team under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. 

Comments


By revealing the power of nature and human agency, our storytelling instills a sense of awe that inspires stewardship and innovation toward the landscapes that shape us. 

Join Our Mailing List

  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • Whatsapp
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page