top of page

A tale as old as Hallow’s Eve: how bobbing for apples came to be

Oct 28
4 min read

You’re at a Halloween Carnival, the scrumptious aroma of sweet pastries and pies drifts all around you. You wander through the aisles of never-ending delicious foods, but one stall catches your attention: a low, wooden trough full of water with floating apples. What’s the story behind how bobbing for apples came to be? Find out in the first article of a collection of spooky, Halloween-themed articles!


Source: Deviant Art, Photo by Raphael Tuck & Sons Co (public domain)
Source: Deviant Art, Photo by Raphael Tuck & Sons Co (public domain)

A chill quivers down your spine as the cold breeze runs down your back on this dark Hallow’s Eve. Your eyes dart back and forth, and out of the corner of your eye, you spot a familiar sight: bright orange gourds carved into limitless faces with vibrant expressions. But how did this tradition start? What about dressing up in costumes? In this collection of bite-sized articles, we will explore the stories and origins behind Halloween’s defining characteristics!


You’re at a Halloween Carnival, there’s rides with blaring lights and tons of smoke effects, a monstrous haunted house with an hour’s long line and the occasional person screaming in fear running straight out the back door; and then there’s the food. The delicious, scrumptious, heavenly aromas of crisp, savoury pies and pastries roam across the fair, like werewolves on the prowl, searching for their next victim, but one stall stands out to you the most: a low, wooden trough full of water with floating apples. So, why do we even dunk our faces into water to try getting a sweet treat? What’s the story behind how bobbing for apples came to be?


A bucket of floating apples in preparation for a round of apple bobbing! (Source: Flickr, Photo by Toby Bradbury)
A bucket of floating apples in preparation for a round of apple bobbing! (Source: Flickr, Photo by Toby Bradbury)

Now, for those who don’t know (which included me before writing this article), bobbing for apples is a game often played on Halloween. In this game, there is generally a large tub or basin filled with water with several apples floating in it. The goal of the game is to chomp onto and catch a floating apple using only your mouth, no hands allowed! It’s a fun game to try, but the origin of bobbing for apples is a lot lovelier than it would appear.


Zooming back in time to Ancient Rome, during the Roman festival honoring Pomona – the nymph (or in some iterations the goddess) of agriculture, young men and women bobbed for apples to predict the fate of their future relationships. Then, in 43 AD, the Romans conquered the British Isles, merging their two traditions of Samhain (the precursor to Halloween and perhaps the topic of my next article ;) ) and the festival of Pomona. In this newly born tradition, women would try to bite an apple in a floating trough, each apple representing a potential husband. If the woman successfully got the apple in one attempt, she would be married to her desired partner. If it took two tries, he would court her, but their relationship was ill-fated. And if she took three or more attempts, they were not destined for each other.


However, this was not the only version of bobbing for apples though; in another version of this tradition, several suitors would compete to see who could chomp onto an apple first, and the winner would marry the woman. In Scotland and Ireland, they created a different version where, after successfully retrieving an apple, the woman would then peel it. Once she had her apple peel, she would twirl the apple peel three times above her head and throw the peel over her shoulder. The shape that the apple peel landed in would be her future husband’s first initial. Similar to the jack-o’-lantern, when Irish immigrants came to the U.S., they also brought apple bobbing with them.


Someone peeling an apple, like how women did their version of bobbing for apples in Scotland and Ireland                         (Source: Wikimedia Commons, Photo by Karl Gruber)
Someone peeling an apple, like how women did their version of bobbing for apples in Scotland and Ireland (Source: Wikimedia Commons, Photo by Karl Gruber)

Now, although we don’t bob for apples to find love anymore, you can still keep celebrating this tradition! You can try chomping on apples in a tub, or try out some newer iterations of this history-packed practice. Instead of using a large amount of still water, a great breeding house for germs, some have started hanging an apple by a string and competing to see who can nom down to the core the fastest. Last year, I saw an even more curious version where, instead of suspending an apple, a string was tied to an apple cider doughnut. So, this coming Halloween, if you see a big wooden tub full of floating apples, remember how far this tradition has come, and maybe even give it a try!



References:


  1. Bradbury, Toby. Bobbing for apples. September 5, 2015. `Flickr. https://www.flickr.com/photos/mrlerone/4994173557.

  2. Cleveland Museum of Art. “Pomona.” Accessed October 20, 2026. https://www.clevelandart.org/art/1948.486.

  3. Gruber, Karl. Apple peeling 4464. January 2015. Wikimedia Commons. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Apple_peeling_4464.JPG.

  4. Thomas, Heather. “The Origins of Halloween Traditions.” Library of Congress Blogs, October 26, 2021. Accessed October 20, 2026. https://blogs.loc.gov/headlinesandheroes/2021/10/the-origins-of-halloween-traditions/.

  5. Warmund, Michele. “Bobbing for Apples: A Tasty Autumn Tradition (Michele Warmund),” October 5, 2022. Accessed October 20, 2026. https://ipm.missouri.edu/meg/2022/10/applebobbing-MW/.

  6. Yesterdays-Paper. Bobbing for Apples. 1907. Deviant Art. https://www.deviantart.com/yesterdays-paper/art/Bobbing-For-Apples-710943141.

Comments


By revealing the power of nature and human agency, our storytelling instills a sense of awe that inspires stewardship and innovation toward the landscapes that shape us. 

Join Our Mailing List

  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • Whatsapp
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page