Social classes and gentrification: how Haussmann’s rebuilding of Paris suppressed revolution
What does the birth of modern Paris have to do with social gentrification, and how does it compare to the modern world?

In the mid-nineteenth century under the direction of Napoleon III, Baron Haussmann set out to radically rebuild Paris from an outdated city with crooked, tight alleyways and health concerns to a modern, broad city shining with white. While the official reasons for this modification were both an economic and health upgrade, the redesign displaced working-class people and dismantled the conditions in Paris that allowed for urban rebellions.

The new structure of Paris specifically targeted urban workers by removing traditional insurrection spaces. Wide boulevards served both an economic and military purpose. Before Haussman’s reforms, Paris was a web of narrow, winding streets that did not have a clear plan. The streets often measured less than 5 to 10 meters in width, which meant that workers could easily erect barricades in an insurrection. These barricades would stop the French military from coming through and reinforcing/stopping the revolt. For example, during the 1848 revolution (before the Haussmann renovation), over 4,000 barricades were built across Paris, and those barricades rendered the army useless due to barricades funneling the army through tight chokepoints and blocking them from getting into the site of the insurrection. Haussmann specifically designed the boulevards in the renovation so that the military could get by and barricades weren’t so easy to erect. The straight streets allowed artillery and cannons to survey entire avenues, while the width also allowed infantry and cavalry to march in a wider formation. The new boulevards, on average, were around 20-30 meters wide.
In order to renovate Paris, Haussmann demolished the central slums of Paris where low-income workers used to live. Rent in the newly-built streets were much higher than what the workers could afford, so they were driven out of their own homes, which is the modern phenomenon now known as gentrification. Haussmann demolished around 20,000 to 30,000 houses, displacing over ⅕ of Paris’ population with urban clearing. The working class were scattered into the arrondissements (most notable being Belleville, Menilmontant, and Montmartre) after the “razing” of the city, which discouraged grouping. The working class used to live together in densely packed streets, which allowed revolutionary ideas to spread fast and far. However, these ideas no longer proliferated as extensively now that low-income laborers were all spread out, making it far harder to stage a revolution from the outskirts than in the center of Paris. The destruction of old neighborhoods also shattered traditional social networks, and they forced workers into new communities. This slowed down the “working together” of the common peoples, and made it so that the old rebellious connections were shattered.

Haussmann also created artificial segregation. Before his time, Paris used to have vertical social integration, where the wealthy lived on the second and third floors while the poorer class lived on the first floor. Haussmann replaced these with exclusively high-end apartment blocks designed for the bourgeoisie, and that created geographic segregation. The rent in central Paris increased exponentially, and in some areas, even above 100%. This made central Paris lived in by almost exclusively nobility. This was intentional, as the French used ornamental balconies, high ceilings, and embellished stone that was aimed at rich tenants. This horizontal division created a socio-geographic line that still can be seen today- a rich, conservative west end of Paris versus a poorer, more radical east end. This split can still be seen in electoral maps today, like the one above.
However, this social gentrification didn’t really work. In 1871, the displaced working class in the eastern half rose up as the Paris Commune because Haussmann concentrated revolutionary tension on the periphery, and linked revolutionaries that had not yet known each other before the restructuring of the city.
The transformation of Paris by Haussmann, while officially being used to upgrade the economy and health in the city, had an ulterior motive to rout revolution and gentrify the city. The actions done to discourage revolution included refurbishing the city, which caused old, narrow, disadvantaged streets to be replaced by wide avenues and forced workers out of central Paris, as well as segregating the city into an affluent west end and a poor east end. Haussmann succeeded initially in dismantling the traditional methods of the revolution. However, in doing so, he created new ways for revolt to form, as shown through the Paris Commune revolt of 1871. Even though the refurbishing of Paris gave us the modern, clean, and beautiful version that we see today, the roots of the restructuring were much more authoritarian than we could have ever known.
References:
Harvey, David. Paris, Capital of Modernity. New York: Routledge, 2003.
Haine, W. Scott. The World of the Paris Café: Sociability among the French Working Class, 1789–1914. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1996.
Marx, Karl. The Civil War in France. New York: International Publishers, 1940. Originally published 1871.
Merriman, John. Massacre: The Life and Death of the Paris Commune of 1871. New York: Basic Books, 2014.





Comments